Milano Pizza Shop

Discover authentic Italian flavors at Milano Pizza Shop in New York City. Enjoy delicious pizzas, chicken parm, garlic knots, and more—affordable prices and amigos favorite dishes. Order today!

Welcome to Milano Pizza Shop

Taste the Difference.

Milano Pizza Shop
Milano Pizza Shop
Milano Pizza Shop
Milano Pizza Shop

Milano Pizza Shop stands as a true gem in New York City, located at 2255 2nd Ave. This lively eatery specializes in Italian cuisine, famous for its delicious pizza and hearty comfort foods. The vibrant atmosphere and rich aromas draw locals and visitors alike into the warm embrace of this bustling kitchen. Regulars rave about Milano’s signature chicken parmigiana and garlic knots, proving that this spot truly celebrates the essence of Italian comfort food. Whether stopping by for a quick slice or a hearty meal with friends and family, Milano Pizza Shop offers an inviting experience that keeps patrons coming back, day after day.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

2255 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10029, United States

Phone

+1 212-996-5141

About

The Culinary Story

Milano Pizza Shop
Milano Pizza Shop
Milano Pizza Shop
Milano Pizza Shop

Milano Pizza Shop shines as a beloved local eatery that provides delicious meals at affordable prices. Located at the bustling corner of 2nd Ave, this establishment is more than just a pizza shop; it’s a neighborhood hub where friends gather, families celebrate occasions, and employees take a break during busy workdays. The menu teems with a vast selection, featuring everything from classic chicken cutlet heroes to hearty lasagna. Customers frequently rave about the freshness of ingredients and the authenticity of flavors throughout the item offerings, ensuring that each meal is a pleasant experience.

Whether it's a simple slice of pepperoni or an elaborate seafood dish, Milano doesn’t hold back on portion sizes or taste.

The shop’s atmosphere buzzes with life, especially during peak times like Tuesday at 2 PM when you’ll find it at full capacity. Lunchtime and dinner periods draw in crowds eager to savor their favorite meals. The record shows that the restaurant's most popular choices include comforting pasta dishes, wallet-friendly cold sandwiches, and satisfying salads. With more than 80 dishes available, there’s something on the menu for everyone.

Notably, Milano Pizza Shop excels in delivering not only great food but also a welcoming environment that feels like home for many locals, creating a sense of community.

For anyone exploring the vibrant neighborhood, Milano serves as a reminder of where culinary artistry meets genuine warmth. With multiple meal options available for dine-in or take-out, there's no reason not to escape into the flavors of Italy right in the heart of New York. To amplify the experience, there’s nothing quite like sharing a garlic knot while catching up with friends in the cozy dining area - a small slice of the community right within its walls.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday11 AM-9:30 PM
  • Monday10:30 AM-9:30 PM
  • Tuesday10:30 AM-9:30 PM
  • Wednesday10:30 AM-9:30 PM
  • Thursday10:30 AM-9:30 PM
  • Friday10:30 AM-9:30 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9:30 PM

Milano Pizza Shop boasts a diverse menu that pleases various tastes. Diners can choose from 80 mouthwatering dishes, including classic Italian pizza pies, hot hero sandwiches, sumptuous pastas, and fresh salads. Each offering stands out with traditional recipes and local ingredients, ensuring quality with every bite. Popular items like the chicken salad and shrimp parmesan demonstrate Milano’s commitment to flavor and satisfaction. With an average price of $11.80, this restaurant proves you don't always have to break the bank to enjoy a delicious meal. The shop also caters to busy customers with a quick take-out option, perfect for a fast lunch or a cozy dinner at home.

Milano Pizza Shop

The exterior of Milano Pizza Shop embodies the charm of a classic New York eatery. Bright red and green signage beckons customers in, while the inviting storefront reveals glimpses of the lively kitchen and friendly staff working diligently. Customers often find seasonal seating options available outside, making it an ideal spot to grab a bite while soaking in the local atmosphere.

This community-centered vibe enhances the dining experience, encouraging friendly conversations and laughter among neighbors. The energy is palpable, creating a perfect backdrop for a casual lunch or an evening dinner with friends.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Milano pizza shop has been in east harlem for a very long time. They have the best pizza in Manhattan. Also the Patty's are good basically every thing they sell is the best. The service is awesome!

M
Maria Q.

Milano Pizza Shop is a hidden gem that absolutely delivers on flavor and service. I stopped in recently and was genuinely impressed by the quality of their pizza and the friendliness of the staff. I ordered a giant sandwich and five trays of food, and it came out hot, fresh, and with the perfect balance of crisp crust, flavorful sauce, and gooey cheese. You can tell they use good ingredients--it really makes a difference. The shop itself was clean and welcoming, with a laid-back vibe that made it easy to relax while waiting. The service was fast and polite, and the staff seemed genuinely happy to be there, which made the whole experience even better. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or ordering a whole pie for the family, Milano Pizza Shop is definitely worth the stop. I'll be back for sure!

M
MALON L.

Amazing Spot to grab a Slice of a Nice Sandwich . Fantastic customer service.

R
Rodney B.

The Chicken Slice. This review is on my go-to slice at this location. Their chicken slice is like no other. It's filling, tasty, crispy, and just enough of the tomato sauce and cheese proportion IMO. You can pick out the chicken and eat them as you go because it does make the slice a bit heavier so its good to take the pieces every other bite. Then the crust, oh my, its not super doughy, but it's fluffy . Anyways, definitely a slice to try here is their chicken slice. The others are okay. Oh, this is a CASH ONLY location so make sure you have at least a $10 to eat well. There's an ATM across 2nd avenue inside of 7 Eleven in case you don't have any cash.

J
Jess B.

The food is DELICIOUS AND AHHMAYYYZING!!!! AMAZING!!!!(TO THOSE WHO WANT TO BE LITERAL AND GRAMMATICALLY CORRECT) IF YOU'RE LOOKING TO ENJOY PIZZA and other foods , welcome to Milano!!!!! Hola everyone!

d
dyanarah m.

Made me feel like a kid again. The pizza is definitely OLD SCHOOL NYC

K
Kimesha A.